support@agenticsnxs.com
1345 West Bay Drive, Suite 202 Belaire Beach, Fl
Get Quote
Their AI Rules Could Create It….
Home➡Business ➡ Their AI Rules Could Create It….

AgenticsNXS · AI Policy & Political Economy

Progressives Once Fought Concentrated Power. Their AI Rules Could Create It.

The movement that broke up Standard Oil is now drafting rules that only the richest AI companies can afford to follow.

Progressives once fought the concentration of industrial power. Today, some of their regulatory proposals risk concentrating technological power.

That is not an accusation of bad faith. It is a warning about how regulation actually works once it leaves the bill-signing ceremony and enters the compliance department.

A Tradition Built Against Bigness

The American progressive movement was born fighting concentrated private power. Theodore Roosevelt made his name as a trustbuster. The Supreme Court broke up Standard Oil in 1911. Louis Brandeis warned of “the curse of bigness” and argued that economic concentration was a threat to democratic self-government, not merely to consumer prices.

That tradition never really died. A decade ago it returned under the name neo-Brandeisian antitrust, and it shaped how a generation of progressive regulators viewed Big Tech.

Which makes the current moment strange.

The New Proposals

Consider what the left’s AI agenda now includes:

  • A federal permission regime. In September, Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Greg Casar introduced legislation to ban artificial superintelligence, pause the most advanced AI development, and create a Cabinet-level Department of Artificial Intelligence. Under the bill, advanced systems would need federal approval before they could be deployed.
  • State frontier-model laws. California’s SB 53 took effect January 1, 2026. New York’s RAISE Act, aligned with it this spring, takes effect January 1, 2027, with a new oversight office inside the state’s Department of Financial Services. Both target models trained above 1026 operations and impose safety-protocol, incident-reporting and disclosure obligations.
  • Growing pressure for more. With AI expected to be a central issue in the 2028 presidential race, the policy energy on the left is moving toward pre-approval, not away from it.

Every one of these proposals is aimed, by its authors, at the largest companies. That is exactly the problem.

How a Permit Becomes a Moat

Regulation imposes fixed costs: lawyers, auditors, red teams, reporting systems, government-relations staff. Fixed costs are trivial for a firm with a hundred billion dollars in the bank. Anthropic alone reported more than $112 billion in cash in its IPO filing. They are fatal for a firm with three engineers and a seed round.

Thresholds are supposed to solve this. Today’s laws apply only above enormous compute levels. But compute gets cheaper every year, and the frontier keeps moving. Startup advocates such as Engine have already warned that New York’s audit and transparency requirements would make it harder for small companies to build. Lawyers who advise startups describe a kind of compliance gravity: rules written for the giants become the standard that investors, customers and insurers expect from everyone.

A pre-approval regime goes further. When the government must say yes before a product ships, the companies that can hire former regulators, staff advisory committees and survive a two-year review gain something no technology can give them: a guarantee that challengers will arrive late, or not at all.

Industrial Era
Agentic Era
Railroads, oil, steel
Compute, models, data
Control of the means of production
Control of the means of intellectual production
Trusts formed by private contract
Moats formed by public regulation
Progressives broke them up
Progressives risk licensing them

The Progressive Case Against the Progressive Proposals

The sharpest version of this argument does not come from the right. It comes from inside the progressive movement itself.

In 2024, then-FTC Chair Lina Khan, the most prominent neo-Brandeisian in Washington, told a room of Y Combinator founders that open-weight models could “liberate startups from the arbitrary whims of closed developers and cloud gatekeepers.” Her point was simple: competition in AI depends on keeping the foundation layer accessible.

A licensing regime for advanced models, by design, makes the foundation layer less accessible. It decides in advance which developers are trusted to build the systems everyone else builds upon. However sincere its motives, that is the opposite of what Brandeis spent his career fighting for.

Yesterday’s industrial monopolists controlled the means of production. Tomorrow’s technological oligopolists could control the means of intellectual production. — Robert Aiisina

The Means of Intellectual Production

The stakes are larger than market share. AI agents are becoming the tools through which people research, write, code, analyze and decide. Whoever controls the most capable systems will shape what millions of people can know and do.

A handful of firms holding that position by winning in the market would be concerning. A handful of firms holding it because federal and state law made it prohibitively expensive for anyone else to try would be far worse, because market positions erode and statutory ones rarely do.

A Pro-Competition Safety Agenda

None of this means AI safety is a pretext. The risks to cybersecurity, biosecurity and critical infrastructure are real, and supporters of the Sanders-Casar approach sincerely believe an unchecked race is the greater danger. Concentration in AI is also driven by the brute economics of compute, not by regulation alone.

But progressives who care about both safety and power should insist on rules that do not hand the incumbents a moat:

  • Regulate dangerous capabilities and uses, not company size. The question should be what a system can do, not who is wealthy enough to file the paperwork.
  • Index and sunset every threshold. Rules that silently expand as compute gets cheaper should require Congress to vote again.
  • Protect open research. Build explicit safe harbors for academic, nonprofit and open-weight development that falls below genuine danger lines.
  • Keep incumbents out of the rule-writing room. No company should help set the standards it will be measured against without strict conflict-of-interest limits.
  • Pair safety with antitrust. Scrutinize the cloud, chip and investment partnerships that already tie the leading labs to the largest platforms.

The Older Progressive Instinct

The trustbusters understood something today’s reformers risk forgetting: concentrated power does not become safe because it is regulated. It becomes permanent.

Progressives were right to fight the monopolists who controlled the means of production. They should be just as vigilant about anyone, public or private, who would control the means of intellectual production.

There are legitimate cybersecurity and biological risks associated with advanced AI. Anthropic’s safety concerns should not be dismissed. To his credit, Amodei has said publicly that he has never advocated a ban on open-weight models, conceding that such a ban would shield U.S. AI companies from competition, “but that has never been my goal.” And Anthropic has itself been on the receiving end of federal power this year, from a supply-chain risk designation at the Pentagon to Commerce Department export restrictions on its own models.

Stated intentions, however, are not a governance structure. Neither Anthropic’s sincerity nor its scars should entitle Anthropic—or OpenAI, Google or Microsoft—to help determine who may compete.

Regulatory capture is a credible risk here, not yet proof of a deliberate monopoly conspiracy. That is precisely why Congress should scrutinize it now, before the rules are written, rather than after.

The WFPX Editorial Angle

The New Robber Barons Want a Federal License to Think

Yesterday’s industrial monopolists sought control of America’s railroads, oil and steel. Tomorrow’s may seek something considerably more valuable: control over America’s access to intelligence itself.

The Closing Argument

America did not become the world’s greatest economic power by asking established corporations for permission to innovate. We became that power by allowing entrepreneurs to challenge them.

Artificial intelligence must not become the exception.

Protect America from the misuse of artificial intelligence. But protect Americans from the monopolization of intelligence itself.

Disclosures

This article is opinion and analysis. It describes potential effects of proposed and enacted AI regulation and does not allege bad faith or unlawful conduct by any lawmaker, regulator or company named. Factual statements reflect public reporting and legislative records as of the publication date.

Nothing herein constitutes investment, legal or tax advice.

© 2026 AgenticsNXS.com · A WFPX Communications & Publishing, LLC property · Largo, Florida · All rights reserved.

Reprint Notice: This article may be excerpted with attribution and a link to AgenticsNXS.com. Full reprints or syndication require written permission from WFPX Communications & Publishing, LLC.

About the Author

Robert Aiisina writes for AgenticsNXS on artificial intelligence, agentic systems and the political economy of technology.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *